We’re passionate about helping you protect what matters most.

Who we are

Naylor Insurance Group was founded by Jared Peterson and JD Moss, two industry veterans with over two decades of experience in the insurance field. Both began their careers as agency owners, gaining hands-on experience that led them to management roles overseeing two of the largest insurance districts in Utah for one of the nation’s top insurance companies. Their journey has been defined by a commitment to excellence—hiring, training, mentoring, and managing top-tier teams, all while maintaining a focus on providing the best possible service.

Now, as the leaders of Naylor Insurance Group, Jared and JD take great pride in offering a first-class experience for all your insurance needs. Drawing on their extensive industry expertise, they’ve curated a portfolio of companies that reflect their dedication to top-tier coverage, protection, and competitive pricing. Their goal is simple: to be your trusted insurance provider for decades to come.

In the early stages of Naylor Insurance Group, Jared and JD welcomed Austin Collie, a business partner of significant value. Austin, whose competitive nature was sharpened during his days as a distinguished football player at BYU and subsequently in the NFL, transitioned fluidly into the business realm. After achieving success in private equity and establishing a strong presence in the startup world, he joined Naylor Insurance Group. Today, Austin applies his enduring passion and dedication to the insurance field, ensuring that Naylor Insurance Group remains a leader in providing exceptional service and protection to all its clients.

At Naylor Insurance Group, we are committed to delivering top-tier service, competitive pricing, and long-term relationships you can trust.

The Team

At Naylor Insurance Group, our team has been carefully selected to reflect the core values of our founders: exceptional service, unbeatable value, and a commitment to always doing what is right. Every team member shares a passion for providing you with an experience that goes beyond the ordinary. We believe in the power of personal, face-to-face interactions, offering expert advice while delivering tremendous value.

With many decades of combined experience in the insurance industry, our team is equipped to handle all your insurance needs—whether you're looking for coverage for your cars, home, recreational vehicles, business, or life insurance. Each member of the Naylor team is knowledgeable and experienced, ready to guide you through the process with care and expertise. Stop by and meet our team today—you won’t be disappointed in how welcomed and cared for you’ll feel!

Jared Peterson

Principal Partner

JD Moss

Principal Partner

Austin Collie

Katie Romero

Principal Partner

VP of Operations

Lori Olsen

Brandon Pedroza

Head of Personal Lines

Personal Lines Agent

Brock Willardson

Jace Peterson

Personal Lines Agent

Personal Lines Agent

Terra Hawker

Sandi Taylor

Commercial Account Representative

Head of Account Relations and Marketing

Brad Haaga

Jeremy Haaga

Commercial Account Executive
CIC, CISR, CRIS

Commercial & Personal Lines Agent

Stacey Williams

Elva Shepard

Commercial & Personal Lines Agent

Account Relations and Marketing

Where We Stand

Our Mission

At Naylor Insurance Group, our mission is to empower individuals and businesses to protect what matters most to them. We strive to provide personalized insurance solutions that offer peace of mind and security in an ever-changing world. By delivering exceptional service, tailored guidance, and comprehensive coverage options, we aim to be our clients’ trusted partner in navigating the complexities of insurance.

Our Vision

Our vision at Naylor Insurance Group is to become the leading provider of insurance solutions known for our unwavering commitment to excellence, integrity, and customer satisfaction. We aspire to continuously innovate and adapt to meet the evolving needs of our clients while maintaining the highest standards of professionalism and ethics. Through collaborative relationships, transparent communication, and a focus on long-term value.